BELKNAP Collision
22 NOVEMBER 1975
BELKNAP COLLISION
At 2130 USS JOHN F. KENNEDY (CV-67) was 70 miles east of Sicily cruising downwind on a heading of 200 degrees. Escorting her were DALE (CG-19), BORDELON (DD-81), CLAUDE V. RICKETTS (DDG-5) and BELKNAP (CG-26), the latter on station off the carrier’s port quarter, 4000 yards astern. At 2145 KENNEDY signaled “CORPEN J PORT 025-12” indicating a turn to port to a new course of 025. This nearly 180-degree turn would place her into the wind to recover the night’s last flight of aircraft. BELKNAP’s watch officers contemplated the course changes necessary to maintain station, resolving to slow to 5 knots, maintain their heading, and watch for the carrier to pass in front. This was not an unsound navigational solution at face value, but it would potentially place the ships on a head-on collision course.
As the carrier neared the end of her turn at 2155 the JOOD aboard KENNEDY reported seeing BELKNAP’s port AND starboard running lights at a range of 1800 yards and a relative bearing of 20 degrees to port. Two minutes later CAPT William A. Gureck arrived on the bridge and noted the range closing without a change in bearing (indicative of a pending collision). He ordered the engines aback and the rudder amidships. BELKNAP’s starboard running light disappeared, but Gureck recognized she would pass port to starboard, dangerously close. At 2200 BELKNAP’s bow glided past the carrier’s cutwater. Then with a mighty crash the superstructure of the cruiser struck the port flight deck overhang, ripping open the outboard refueling lines. JP5 poured into the cruiser’s wreckage where electrical sparks from torn wires ignited an intense fire.
The larger carrier fared better. Her fires were extinguished in 10 minutes; her front catapults were knocked off-line, and her aircraft were diverted to NAS Sigonella. Aboard BELKNAP the story was much worse. Her superstructure was shredded nearly to deck level. Fires burned so intensely that the aluminum of the remaining superstructure melted. Ammunition for the 3″/50 gun cooked-off, but damage control kept the fires from reaching the 5″ shell magazine or the Terrier ASROC magazine (this latter containing six M-45 nuclear warheads). Fifty-five sailors jumped overboard for their lives. Seven BELKNAP sailors died and 47 were injured. One sailor aboard KENNEDY later died of smoke inhalation.
The event grabbed the attention of naval architects who had promoted the use of lightweight aluminum in warship construction. However, the phase out of such construction did not finally occur until the Arleigh Burke-class destroyers of the 1990s. BELKNAP was towed to Philadelphia where she was repaired and returned to front-line Cold War service until her decommissioning in 1995.
Watch for more “Today in Naval History” 27 NOV 26
CAPT James Bloom, Ret.
Department of the Navy. JAG Manual Investigation to inquire into the circumstances surrounding the collision between USS JOHN F. KENNEDY (CV 67) and USS BELKNAP (CG 26) which occurred on 22 November 1975, (with endorsements), dtd. 31 December 1975. AT: http://www.jag.navy.mil/library/investigations/ USS_KENNEDY_and_BELKNAP_2075_pt_1.pdf, retrieved 11 October 2012.
“On a Collision Course, USS JOHN F. KENNEDY (CV-67) and the USS BELKNAP (CG-26).” AT: http://home.comcast.net/~cshortridge/NAVALART/ON_A_COLLISION_COURSE.pdf, retrieved 11 October 2012.
Sweetman, Jack. American Naval History: An Illustrated Chronology of the U.S. Navy and Marine Corps, 1775-Present, 3rd ed. Annapolis, MD: USNI Press, 2002, p. 243.
ADDITIONAL NOTES: BELKNAP’s OOD of this night, LTJG Kenneth M. Knull, was eventually found guilty of negligence and failure to follow orders. Ironically this collision occurred on the 12th anniversary of President John F. Kennedy’s assassination.
The slow phase-out of aluminum would become an issue again 12 years later when USS STARK (FFG-31) was struck with two Iraqi Exocet missiles. Stark had been built five years after this BELKNAP collision, yet continued to utilize aluminum in her construction. This latter incident was also the end of shipboard uniforms of Certified Navy Twill (CNT). Several STARK sailors had their burns overcoated with melted polyester, which necessitated painful, scar-forming removal.
Sailors never miss an opportunity to poke fun despite dire circumstances. Following this event KENNEDY was given several colorful nicknames, such as “Can Opener” and “Jack the Tin Can Killer.”
BELKNAP remembers George Eugene Belknap (1832-1903) who commanded the Union gunboat USS CANONICUS during the Civil War and went on to serve 47 years, the last five at the rank of RADM.
